Me: I’m starting to think that if all the Jews took off tomorrow not much would be different. The Woke movement would keep going full steam along with the degeneration of society. Porn? The Jewish porn companies would simply be taken over by Gentiles. A lot of this stuff may well have been kicked off by Jews but right now, it’s on autopilot so much that if the Jews left, nothing would change. Our policy on Israel would change though.
Commenter: What you’re describing has a name. It’s called ideological inertia. After the Jewish communists and Bolsheviks took over Russia they indoctrinated everybody into communism. At some point the Jews were mostly thrown out of power (largely by Stalin), but communist ideological inertia stuck around and was such that the USSR went on trying (and failing) to make communism work for another half century.
If all the Jews suddenly disappeared then Cultural Marxism (which Jews founded and foisted on the West to serve their interests just as the Jews in the USSR foisted Communism Classic on Russia to suit their interests there) may well stick around for awhile, sure.
True-believing gentiles would continue trying, and failing, to make Cultural Marxism (diversity and multiculturalism, etc.) work, just as true-believing communists like Khrushchev and Brezhnev tried to make communism work.
That’s just the nature of media conditioning and intrinsic to the nature of organizations which perpetuate themselves by promoting true believers within. The Soviet leadership spent decades promoting true-believing communists long after the Jews were mostly removed from power.
But at least the Jews who originally created and promoted Cultural Marxism would be gone and no longer in a position of power to cynically and dishonestly push an ideology which they know to not be in their host’s genuine interests (but only their own).
Hence, Cultural Marxism, like Communism Classic before it, would be able to eventually fall apart – as both ideologies are ultimately unworkable, based on lies, and are counter to human nature (human nature being self-interested and tribal and not like eusocial insects as communism assumes or non-tribal as Cultural Marxism assumes).
For a wound to heal, you must get rid of the root cause of the the infection which makes it fester – and, as Lindsay points out, even when you do, the patient dies anyways, as one might fear the West would regardless of whether we get rid of the Jews or not.
I definitely agree with his point here. He’s a very smart guy, he writes well, and this idea of his is an excellent concept. “Ideological inertia” – nice!
Commenter: But to have any chance at survival then the infection (Jews) must be removed – at least from positions of power in media, government, law, politics and academia – and then the healing process can occur. Thus, for a gentile to argue “but it might not work” and therefore “you should not give the patient antibiotics” is an argument born of either (1) stupidity or (2) maliciousness.
There are dramatic examples where Jews were expelled in a very deliberate way because the harm that they were doing was well understood, and it was seen as necessary to get rid of them to achieve recovery.
You see this in the expulsion of Jews from Spain in 1492, which is also the year that marks the beginning of the Spanish Golden Age.
You also see it when the Jews were removed from public life at the end of the Weimar period which resulted in an immediate and dramatic economic and cultural renaissance.
So, when Jewish expulsion is done in a very conscious manner – and when the jilted parasite doesn’t then lead a coalition of nations against you in vengeance – the recovery can indeed be rapid, dramatic and sustainable.
As you can see he’s also a very nasty antisemite like so many on that site. I certainly don’t advocate getting rid of the Jews in the West or the US. If the Cultural Left is truly unsustainable as he says, then it will die out at some point anyway, Jews or no Jews.
I don’t believe the Cultural Left was created by Jews, but there were some Jews who were prominent in it. Critical Race Theory was actually started by Blacks in academia as you might expect. The White-hating and White demonization comes straight from these radical Blacks. Blacks push White-hating far more than Jews do if you ask me.
The Cultural Left actually blossomed with the fall of Communism in the Soviet Bloc in 1989-1991. The Western Left was in chaos as Marxism was seen as a failed ideology. What to do? Turn Republican, go fascist, and vote Trump? Nope. Instead they tried to salvage what they could of Marxism by downplaying Marxist economics and instead substituting race, sexual orientation, nationality, ethnicity, sexual identity, etc. with classic Marxist theory.
I believe that the same woman who invented CRT (Kimberly Crawford?) also invented Third Wave Intersectional Feminism. Law professor Derrick Bell was also prominent in this movement. The Woke movement or the Cultural Left is all seated in Third Wave intersectional feminism.
It posits that people suffer from more oppressions than one. For instance, a Black woman suffers from being Black and also for being a woman. That’s the intersectional part. There’s probably something to it but by now this theory has gone crazy and it’s not doing much good.
So if you want to get down to it, Crenshaw and Bell invented Cultural Marxism, though of course all of these things had their roots in the women’s, Black, Hispanic, gay, etc. Liberation movements of the 1960’s. There were some Jews prominent in these movements but it would be silly to call them Jewish movements.
Anyway, feminism is now run by mostly Gentile women, not Jews. Black antiracism is run by Blacks and not Jews. Hispanic rights is run by Hispanics and not Jews. Gay rights is run by gay Gentiles and not Jews. It doesn’t much matter who kicked off these movements if they’ve all gone automatic by now.
I don’t believe Jews “founded Communism.” That’s just bullshit. Most Communists were Gentiles. In 1917, 7
Only a small sliver of Russian Jews were Bolsheviks, no more than 1
Also I looked at the list of leading Bolsheviks early on and I counted as many Latvians as Jews! Latvians! Latvians are known as hardcore Commie-haters. Shall we blame Latvians for starting Bolshevism? The Bolsheviks’ supporters were mostly Russian Gentile urban workers and demobbed soldiers from the war. There was also some support in the countryside. Stalin fled to a remote village in Siberia inhabited by a different ethnic group. He found that he fit right as all of these Siberian ethnic types were already hardcore revolutionaries and communists!
I really get tired of this Bolshevik Jews arguments and at its core, it’s simply straight up Nazism. One of the main thing Hitler had against the Jews was that according to him, they were all Communists.
There had been some prominent Communist movements in Russia led by Rosa Luxembourg, Karl Liebneckt, etc. There was even a short lived Communist republic in Bavaria. Apparently these uprisings really freaked the German middle class out and hence led to an anti-Communist ideological fervor among the masses. So these revolutions probably informed Hitler’s view.
I think the whole argument is just bullshit and furthermore, it’s toxic because it’s not just antisemitism, some of which might be palatable if it’s true, but instead it’s full-blown Nazism, and I ain’t supporting any of that BS!
How on Earth did these early Jewish Bolsheviks found Communism to benefit the Jews? How did they benefit? A lot of Russian Jews probably had some money and lost most of it after Communism. They couldn’t be bankers or businessmen anymore.
I’m not seeing how their group and only their group benefited. Instead Communism was intended to benefit the vast majority of impoverished Russian Gentile peasants and urban workers, probably very few of whom were Jews. The Russian Bolsheviks were actually very selfless. Communism screwed most Jews over but it helped the Gentiles immensely. They were the opposite of Jewish ethnic activists.
Furthermore, while we already decided that the Cultural Left was not started by Jews, it’s hard to make an argument that Jews started it to benefit their own kind and screw over the Gentiles. How on Earth do Jews benefit from the Cultural Left? It advocates for the rights of women, Blacks, Hispanics, gays, trannies, etc. the vast majority of whom are not Jewish. If anything Cultural Left Jews were selfless.
The bit about removing Jews from power in the US is something I cannot support. That’s exactly what the Nazis did before they started killing them. It’s also what Arab governments did to the Arab Jews after 1948. This was then followed by pogroms in which hundreds of Jews were murdered. So this sort of thing – removal from public life – not only has a bad history but it also seems to lead, probably inevitably, to Jews getting killed.
He’s really going to have to prove his case that throwing out the Spanish Jews (who hadn’t much power anyway) led to the Golden Age of Spain. They also threw out the Muslims at that time and that may have been the most important factor.
He’s also going to have to prove his case that the removal of Jews from power and the arts in Germany led to an economic and cultural renaissance.
If these things are true, I’ll definitely believe them though I don’t wish to. I believe all sorts of things I don’t want to that make me feel uncomfortable. But I’m committed to the truth and I have no desire to believe lies about worldly matters.
If anyone wants to chime in either way on this rather incendiary charge, go right ahead.