Delphi Murders Update March 26, 2021

This post has now been updated. See here for the April 4 update. It’s even crazier than this update!

First, a pitch for support for this website and our sleuthing group:

People are donating lots of money to Delphi podcasters Mike Greeno and Gray Hughes, which is their right. Gray makes over $100,000/year from his podcasts, which is fine by me. I don’t agree that any of these people are grifters as everyone says. A grifter is literally a criminal fraudster and he is breaking the law.

The people paying Hughes and Greeno clearly feel that they are getting their money’s worth. But what shocks me is how little these men give their audiences in return for their purchases. Gray’s videos run to 3-4 hours and may contain five minutes of useful material if you are lucky during that time. Greeno’s videos are almost completely worthless, and group members who have spoken to him told me he has nothing new to add to the case.

Which brings me to the question, why not donate to our enterprise here? It’s a much better purchase for your money than throwing money at Hughes and Greeno, for which you get almost nothing in return. And you won’t by enriching someone who is already wealthy like Hughes. I live on a fixed income which is barely above the poverty level. Our group is clearly the best Delphi sleuthing group on the Internet by far.

Unlike any other sleuthers, we have actually determined the main suspect in the case, and we have a pretty good idea of what happened during the crime and what the crime scene looked like. And most of what we have reported is based on solid sources such as search party members, official case documents, and detectives in other areas of LE that leak to us what they’ve heard via the LE grapevine. No one else has come close to uncovering the amount and quality of information we have, and almost the entire community rejects our findings even though they are correct.

So why waste your money on Hughes and Greeno? Why not donate to the best Delphi sleuthing team of all by donating to me, leader of a group of 230+ sleuthers who have been working on the case for four years now? How about getting your money’s worth?

Support the best Delphi sleuthing group of all!

This post is very long. It runs to 29 pages. I’m sorry but I’m afflicted with both graphomania and logorrhea (same thing). We writers love to write and once we get started, we just can’t quit, like any other addiction to dope, gambling, sex, porn, or whatever. Except you never get the peak high, and there’s no post-high crash. The high continues the whole time, and there’s relief when you’re done as in an accomplished chore instead of a crash. Sort of, “I’m sure glad that’s over.” We love it yet it’s a chore. Kind of like, you know, life.

You just can’t stop. Supposedly writing too much is a sign of a lousy writer, but then we must convict Balzac and Dickens, not to mention encyclopedists like Pynchon and the king of the graphomaniacs, Proust. I’d rather not do that.

It’s not so much the sign of a lousy writer as the sign of a writer, as in a born writer, a real writer. Just as there are men and real men, so there are writers and real writers.

Obviously it’s a flaw. It violates White’s Manual of Style (Keep it simple, stupid) and a lot of other things, including the reader’s precious time. But all great things come with flaws just as there is a bit of good in even most horrors.

Anyway, what do you think editors are for? To mop up our Niagra of words, that’s what.

A bit here on my ever-growing army of critics. I’ve met some new folks lately, and they all say, “You know, I heard all these horrible things about you, but I wasn’t sure if they were true. Now that I contacted you, I know it’s all garbage. You’re like the nicest guy in the world.” Well, yeah. The obvious conclusion of someone who really knows me. Which is like…just about no one.

If you hate me so much, why do you read? I don’t get it. I don’t read people I hate. I might use their prose for toilet paper or lining bird cages, but I certainly won’t read it. I have better things to do, like enjoying life instead of hating it like you do. If you hate me that much, just go away. Don’t read. Unless you’re someone to whom hate is as valuable as oxygen. In that case, do come and get your fix.

One more thing. Nothing the critics ever said about me is true except that I’m broke, don’t have a regular job, and at one point my car broke down and I didn’t have the money to fix it. None of the sexual proclivities or obsessions they say I have are true. I don’t mind people who think that way, but it’s not for me, sorry. Once again, anyone who really knows me figures this out. Which, once again, is like, just about nobody.

How bout one more one more thing, just to try your patience? There’s a lot of graphic commentary below, including gruesome descriptions of the brutal murders of two young teenage girls. True crime is a nasty beast by its nature. There’s no way to pretty up this pig. If your true crime commentary isn’t brutal, you’re avoiding the facts. If you have a sensitive stomach about such things, just don’t read. Go read about flowers or something instead.

Oh, one more two more things. There are are blown up and edited to Hell images below taken from a helicopter hovering over the crime scene. In the images, some can make out the outlines of the two young victims. Not much is visible. They may as well be stick figures. Nevertheless, a lot of tender folks freak out on such things. So don’t look at them. Have a cup of coffee and think of sunshine and smiles instead.

Oh and one more three things. I would like to officially thank “Cory Ahlm” and “Ryan Vanslooten,” whoever the Hell they are, assuming they even exist in the first place, two of my very best friends going so far back I can’t even remember when we first met. They’ve been with me from the start and the start of this case, and I couldn’t have done anything without them. I could barely have existed without them! Speaking of which, I wish I was in California! The weather here is fit for Polar Bears and few else. By the way, I’ve heard of doppelgangers, but who ever thought there could be a double doppelganger? Only in the movies!

This will be a follow-on to my earlier post here. Anything published in the early post that has not changed will not be republished here. Only new items and old items that have changed will be listed here.

First of all, about the purpose of this website. The purpose of this site has simply been a clearinghouse for rumors about the Delphi Murders on Abby Williams and Libby German in Delphi, Indiana, on February 13, 2017. That’s all we ever wrote. It’s true we were fast and loose with some of those rumors, reporting them as truth, and that is unfortunate. But that’s how it goes in this business.

So every time you hear people bashing the Hell out of this site for something we printed, keep in mind that that was just some rumor we heard and printed. That’s all it ever was. Of course, we have been trying to winnow the rumors down into those we have more confidence and less confidence in from the very start, but that’s easier said than done.

I would estimate that 95% of the rumors I have printed about this case have proven to be false. In fact, 95% of anything you have heard about this case anywhere over time is probably false.

I suppose I should go over some of these old dead rumors because idiots keep accusing us of pushing these theories. Now, when I say a rumor is considered dead, not credible, false, not true, etc., please leave me alone and quit accusing me of pushing an old story I’ve long since discredited. I will start with dead rumors or highly dubious rumors. After I do that, I will discuss rumors that have more credibility.

Dead or Highly Dubious Rumors

The barn theory: Has to do with the Mears barn across the street from Ron Logan’s house. We have a photo of cadaver dogs searching the barn. Also there was a small shrine with flowers inside the structure. And the owners acted very strange when we asked if the barn had been used in the crime. The barn theory is continuing to be pushed by a woman who says the girls were removed from the area, taken to the barn, killed there, and then returned to the dump site. Despite all of this, we regard the barn story as dead.

The initial K was carved in trees at the crime scene. We got this secondhand from a LE source. Turns out it was a bad rumor. As you can see, LE sources are not so reliable.

The White Dodge Dart: We formerly thought this had something to do with the crime. Turns out it was a great big dead end, one of many in this case. A white Dodge Dart is not involved in the case.

The crime had Satanic overtones. Indeed, we theorized this in the early days after the crime. In part it was due to bizarre reports from people who saw crime scene photos that the crime appeared to have occult or Satanic overtones. We now feel that this is false. There is no evidence of occult or Satanic overtones to this crime.

A previous report said that Abby was raped via PIV sex and fluids were left at the scene. This rumor is now judged false. The rumor also stated that the motive of the crime was the rape of Abby Williams. This is also false.

A previous report stated that the girls were bound with ropes around their backs. We judge that false. Instead, we believe that they were handcuffed.

A previous report said that the crime scene “begins in the Robertson’s backyard and continues for 1,000 feet.” We regard this as unconfirmed to say the least. Probably best disregarded for now.

A previous report said that at least two searchers touched the bodies and one tried to revive the girls with mouth to mouth resuscitation. We now regard this rumor as probably false and unconfirmed to say the least. There’s no evidence for it at the moment.

A previous report said that the cause of death of Abby Williams was a knife wound to the heart. We now judge this as rumor as false. Instead, we feel, via Leaker, that Abby was struck over the head with a blunt object (we believe it was the killer’s gun). She was also stabbed in the main artery of her neck. It is not known which assault was fatal.

A previous report said that some sort of bleach or toilet bowl cleaner was thrown on the girls’ bodies, in particular their genitalia, in order to destroy DNA evidence of the crime. This is rumor is unconfirmed.

Our POI: We had a sleuthing group with 200 members. I had a POI and I built quite a large case against him. In fact, LE contacted us and asked us to send them everything we had on this man. In addition, the Indiana State Police were verified as harassing this man at one point by repeatedly calling him on the phone. I know the name of the detective who was doing that, too. In addition, this man was a suspect according to the FBI, who tricked him into coming up to Michigan, only to detain and get a DNA sample from him.

As you can see this man was a considered a suspect by both the FBI and the ISP, so please stop accusing us of harassing him. We never published his name one time over the years, and I will not do it now. I won’t even publish his initials. We had a private pay-only group where we discussed him, but that was it. That’s like talking about someone within the confines of a private home. This man also made a series of videos where he seemed to be confessing to being the Bridge Guy (the UNSUB in the murders). In addition, he seemed to be taunting LE and viewers in these videos. Excuse me for suspecting that a guy who making videos almost literally confessing to being BG might actually be the killer!

This man is not a very nice person, but I no longer feel that he had anything to do with this crime. His quasi-confessions go down on the list of false confessions in this case. Counting hazy cases like this, I count four false confessions so far.

I would apologize to him  for falsely accusing him behind closed doors, but he threatened to murder me many times, so I’ll pass on that. In cases like these, possible suspects who seem like good possibilities for being the culprit are often run through the ringer, only to be dismissed. They’re often pretty suspicious people. I’d appreciate it if people would leave this fellow alone. He’s not very pleasant anyway.

Rumors That Have More Credibility

The girls’ bodies were violated with sticks and branches. We have caught Hell and high water for this one, however, this rumor has some staying power.

It showed up quickly within a week of the murders when a local young man published photos of the crime scene that he had somehow obtained. He described the murders as “occult-like” and wondered if there was an occult or Satanic connection. He described a branch plunged into the body of one of the girls.

Next, we received confirmation of this via an associate of a detective working on the case. He had told his SO details about the case, and we got the data from there. This person said the detective had told them that the girls’ bodies were violated with sticks and branches, in particular, that sticks had been inserted into the girls’ vaginas and anuses. That sounds pretty awful but this is one terrible crime.

Finally, a woman came to me and apologized. She said she had been mad at me for spreading this rumor but she had recently been able to confirm its truth via a detective in another area of LE who had seen crime scene photos. This man added that Abby had a branch plunged into her body just below her solar plexus in her chest. So far we have three verfications of this rumor, two from people who saw crime scene photos and two from LE with some overlap. Nevertheless, we still regard this rumor as unconfirmed though definitely possible with the two LE confirmations.

And the more you learn about this crime, believe me, the more you would not be surprised at the cruelty and bizarreness of abusing these girls’ bodies in this way because that seemed to be a major focus on the crime – violating, dishonoring, shaming, and debasing these girls with cruelty and contempt and then posing them in a degrading and humiliating manner. In addition, the killer’s behavior a few hours after the crime was another taunt and a cruel dancing on these girls’ graves after their deaths. This is one Hell of a dark crime.

One girl was pregnant: This has been a rumor from the very first weeks after the crime. The same woman above also apologized for being mad at me over this rumor. However, she told me that she was able to confirm this rumor via a sheriff’s deputy in nearby county. Nevertheless, I suppose it remains formally unverified, and keep in mind some of our LE sources have told us false things. The rumor is that one girl was in the very early stages of pregnancy. We are not going to say which girl it was. Based on the recent verification we got from LE, we regard as it quite possibly true, but it would be nice to get some more confirmation.

A longstanding rumor is that Libby German was killed by a deep knife cut to her neck. This was recently confirmed by a new source named Leaker, who I regard as credible. Apparently his wife accessed documents relating to the case at her job at the courthouse. I have also verified this sad fact via the girl’s own mother who saw the wound. This rumor is 100% confirmed.

A previous report said that Libby was attacked with a gut knife in her abdomen, resulting in a partial disembowelment of this poor girl. If this wound took place, it was after she was dead. A gut knife is one of the knives that would be present in that deer kit (a deer hunter’s kit containing five knives) that BG has around his waist. Partial verification of this is in the form of reports of detectives going around to local hardware stores in the weeks after the murders asking if anyone had bought a gut knife recently.

Presumably one of the wounds to the girl(s) was via this sort of a knife. On the other hand there is a new rumor that a gut knife was left at the scene. This man also lists a number of items the killer left at the scene that stretches credulity. Leaving a gut knife at the scene is unverified and seems quite dubious. A knife with no DNA? That the girl was attacked in this terrible manner is also completely unconfirmed. However, detectives definitely feel that a gut knife was used in this crime.

New Information from Leigh Kerr (Leaker)

Quite a bit of new information came out a few weeks ago via an appearance by a man named Leaker, identified above. He is a pastor who lives in Lafayette. His access to investigation documents is described above. Leaker was extremely controversial, yet for a variety of reasons, I regard him as credible. He gave us a lot of new information, much of which may be correct. Keep in mind that both local LE and FBI have commented on Leaker’s remarks, saying that nothing he said was true. But that is to be expected.

Leaker says that there is a prime suspect in the case. Based on the facts laid out, he can only mean a Delphi resident, recently moved to Monticello, who I will call Mr. X. I could use his initials but that doesn’t seem right. This man is either the prime suspect or Leaker is trying to frame him, one or the other. I think he’s the prime suspect.

According to Leaker, Mr. X was involved in the search party. At some point during the searching, he claimed to have lost his keys. His truck was parked overnight, hidden in the cemetery right above where the girls were found. It was still there the next day when the cemetery was full of police vehicles. This is because Mr. X lost his keys at some point. I believe he claims to have lost his keys while searching. Although Mr. X claims that he called his wife to come bring an extra set of car keys, his truck stayed there overnight and into the next day, which seems odd. On the afternoon after the bodies were found, Mr. X’s truck was towed.

At 6 PM, Mr. X asked permission to search Ron Logan’s land. Permission was granted. This request can be linked to the truck hidden at the cemetery as this is where he obviously was parked when he made this request, however, we do not know when the truck arrived there. Mr. X then searched Logan’s land. Although it was dusk, it would seem to be hard to miss the girls right below where his truck was parked.

Mr. X was back searching in the area on Logan’s land at 12:30 PM February 14. He and 1-3 other persons spotted the girls bodies. There is a rumor that Mr. X looked through his binoculars, spotted a deer, and then looked down and saw the girls. This seems credible to me although some say that LE just made this up as a ruse. The searchers did not come very close to the bodies. Who all found the bodies is still quite up in the air. After he found the bodies, there is a rumor that Mr. X was so traumatized that he ran from the scene. He then needed psychotherapy for some time after discovering the bodies. Both of those behaviors seem pretty over the top, even for such a gruesome crime.

Mr. X is the prime suspect for a variety of reasons. For one, there was a small change in his story.

Leaker said, in shocking news, that Mr. X’s phone was pinging at the abandoned Child Protective Services (CPS) building for several hours around the time of the murders. It is the opinion of LE that the killer parked at the CPS building while he committed his crimes. There vehicle may have been a truck. A persistent yet unconfirmed rumor is that it was a white truck. However, Mr. X’s truck is orange. LE would like very much to speak for anyone who spotted that truck at the CPS building during that time to contact LE. If the truck can be linked to Mr. X, an arrest will be possible.

Mr. X does not have a good excuse for his phone pinging at the CPS building for hours. However, cellphone data is generally not admissible in court, and anyway, Mr. X can always say that he was elsewhere and his phone just happened to be pinging at the CPS building looking for a signal, so this evidence cannot be used in court. However, it is suspicious to say the very least. If Mr. X’s truck was not there the whole time, it is possible that he left his phone at the building for several hours while he committed the crime. That way his phone could not be tracked to the crime scene.

Leaker says that Mr. X had an alibi, a friend of his. This friend says he saw Mr. X elsewhere in town around the time of the murders. LE was unable to break Mr. X’s alibi via his friend. It is considered to be a solid alibi in terms of taking the case to court. Unfortunately, this friend is has since died. This complicates the case immeasurably.

According to Leaker, the only DNA on the girls’ bodies is from Kelsi, Libby’s sister. Kelsi has been cleared. Mr. X’s DNA is in the area, but he was part of the search team that discovered the bodies, so it’s not usable. Assuming he did it, see how he contaminated the scene by finding the bodies?

Leaker also said that there were religious aspects to the murders. Although the exact nature of these aspects is unknown, a rumor that a crucifix was left at the site seems credible.

Leaker also said that the girls’ bodies were posed in a sexual tableau. This seems to be correct. More on that below.

A previous report said that the killer took photos or video of the crime and sent it to Abby’s phone after the murders. This is correct, and I have additional evidence that will prove this.

A previous report noted, in stunning news, that the killer had known Libby for 3-4 months before the murders via social media. According to Leaker, this is correct. The killer contacted Libby on social media using the “catfish” of a young man aged 19. Libby had gotten smitten with this young man and wanted to meet him. The catfish appears to have been the killer himself. Leaker says the second sketch is a sketch of the catfish photo that the killer used to lure Libby on Snapchat where she was catfished. One of Libby’s friends had seen a photo of the catfish, and her description of it is what the second sketch is based on.

At the start of this case, LE said “be careful of what your kids are doing on social media.” The usual idiots who have swarmed this case from Day One have insisted all this time that that means nothing. However, we have been reporting for some time on here that the girls may have been catfished via social media. In fact, we were ripped up pretty severely for promoting that theory. As with so many aspects of this case, a number of the “wild, outrageous, and offensive stories” we were reporting on here from the start are turning out to be true. It’s no surprise to me. I’m a professional journalist. I have a BA in Journalism. I worked as an assistant editor of a magazine. This is one of my professions.

According to Leaker, LE feels that Libby may have posted on Snapchat that she was going to the bridge that day. We reported in a previous post that the trip was not a last minute decision, and instead, adults were discussing it in local bars on Friday night. We have been saying all along that the killer must have known the girls were going to be there that day, and he came quite amply prepared to commit this specific crime. The crime may have been plotted for four months prior to carrying it out. You can see how BG was loaded up with all that murder equipment. He’d obviously planned this out in advance.

Of course, we have been bashed for this too, and an absolutely insane theory that fails all logic tests that the killer came to the bridge that day looking to kill any victim that he might happen to spot there has been suggested in its stead. This theory fails so badly on logic alone that it’s amazing how much traction it got.

Too many people on this case seem to be afflicted with a disorder called Pathological Doubting Disorder. They have pathologically doubted everything and anything that anyone ever said about this crime. They beat their fists on the table endlessly that only verified information, not rumors, must be discussed. The problem here is that LE hasn’t told us a damned thing. If we were restricted to merely discussing what has been verified by LE, there’d be nothing to talk about. We’d all be sitting around talking about the weather instead.

Leaker also said that if the catfish can be connected to Mr. X, an arrest will be possible.

However, this will be hard to do. All attempts to find the killer’s IP addresses or texts or photos of the catfish on Snapchat have come up empty for whatever reason.

According to Leaker, Mr. X has completely cooperated with the investigation. At the time of the crime, Mr. X lived two miles from the crime scene.

Leaker also said that the crime was committed in a ravine that is hard to see from most angles. It may also be sheltered sound-wise too.

Leaker said there is more audio on Libby’s phone, but it is so garbled and hard to hear that LE did not feel it would be useful to the general public. However, Leaker said that LE cleaned the audio up and transcribed it as best as they could. BG accosted the girls and appears to have pulled his gun on them.

In brand new information, apparently one of the trail cams at the south end of the bridge where the abduction took place had been disabled. LE feels it was disabled prior to the crime. So BG came to the south end of the bridge before the crime occurred and disabled the camera. Once again, we see forward planning for this crime.

According to Leaker, after BG accosted the girls, he said he was a police officer and they were trespassing on private property (they were not). He said he had spotted them with his binoculars and had come to arrest them. I can now confirm that BG did have binoculars. BG then handcuffed the girls and said, “Down the hill.” The girls pleaded with him to let them go, that they are sorry and they won’t do it again, etc. but he told them they are under arrest.

Jesus Christ, this case is sad! Just thinking about that scenario with those girls pleading to be let go breaks my heart!

At the bottom of the hill, Libby’s shoe was found by searchers. To me this implies that she tried to run. How else does she lose her shoe?

What follows, according to the families of the girls who LE played the tape for, is six minutes of garbled conversation in which the girls and BG are talking as they walk through the woods, the sound of the forest floor crunching beneath their feet. At the six minute mark, BG and the girls can be heard starting to cross the creek, so the girls were definitely walked across the creek. This has been an odd source of contention. At that point, LE shut off the tape.

Leaker says that the audio continues after the girls crossed the creek and were marched to the kill zone, which appears to have been selected and prepared beforehand due to its visual and auditory seclusion. Next you hear a loud scream followed by a loud thump. This is apparently poor Abby screaming. The thump sound is thought to be BG hitting her over the head with a blunt object. We believe he hit her with the butt end of the handgun you can see in his right hand pocket of his jacket on the BG video. Abby may well have been knocked out cold by this blow.

Leaker concurred that Libby died via a deep knife wound to the throat. He also said that the murder weapon was a hunting knife.

I Was Able to Obtain Official Document(s) Relating to the Case!

And now I can release brand new information! I was able to obtain anywhere from 1-10 documents from the investigation. I am making the claim vague in this way because I have to protect the person I got this data from. They very much do not want it getting out that they were given these document(s). So I have to cover my tracks pretty well here because I don’t want to reveal my sources.

I’m an educated and trained journalist. One of the things we learned in J-school is that you have to protect your sources and value their confidentiality at all costs. We are supposed to go to jail instead of revealing our sources, and some of us have.

Therefore it is disconcerting to see constant accusations of me making up rumors or theories about this crime out of whole cloth. I can’t do that. That’s a gross violation of journalistic ethics, and I’m an ethical journalist. I’m not talking about beating around the bushes of masking facts and truths as I did above with the documents statement. Journalists have lost their careers over doing that, and good luck getting hired again afterwards. It’s as bad as scientific misconduct is for a scientist.

Obviously I’ve been dying to get a hold of official documents about this case for four years now. We did briefly have contacts with a few LE sources, but they didn’t tell us a lot. We had maybe one LE source every two years on this case. So we don’t have any “special sources” about this case as my critics claim. What special sources? What are they talking about?

I assure you that it’s completely legal for the possessor of these document(s) to possess them. That’s all I’m going to say about that.

The document(s) came to me from the owner who lawfully possessed them..

The document(s) came from either LE or from the judicial system or possibly both at the same time. They are signed by official(s).

I was able to learn a number of things about this case from these document(s), some that have been released before, but others that have never been released or even rumored anywhere. I am absolutely certain of the truth of everything I write below based on my belief that these document(s) are authentic.

BG discharged a gun in the course of this crime. Perhaps the most amazing information of all is that this was a gun crime! The gun used was no doubt the one that can be seen in the right jacked pocket of BG. It’s a handgun. After the “guys” in the video, he apparently pulled his gun out and pointed it at the girls. He controlled them with the gun. We have assumed that from the very start of this case. But we never had any idea that a gun was fired during this crime!

We don’t know how the gun was used. We only know that it was discharged. Where, how, and why we don’t know. However, spent cartridges were found by LE, who says they were fired by BG. Did he fire them into the girls’ dead bodies? No idea. How does LE they know that the spent cartridges they found were fired by BG? No idea. But they do have spent cartridges from this crime and they are trying to find the gun used to fire them in order to do ballistics tests on it.

Leaker said that BG had binoculars. He told the girls when he accosted them that he had spotted them trespassing through his binoculars and he decided to come and arrest them. I can now verify Leaker’s statement because the document mentions binoculars. LE is looking for binoculars that were used in the crime.

There is more shocking information that was touched on earlier. I mentioned above that there was a rumor that BG had taken photos and video and had sent them to Abby’s phone after the crime. This rumor was affirmed by Leaker. However, I can now prove this is true because LE is looking for photos, videos, film, cameras, and/or videocameras. Any of those. Video were recorded by BG as he committed this crime. So he videotaped his crime as he committed it. Some people say they can see a Go Pro on BG’s person. We are uncertain about this.

Now how could LE possibly know that BG took video of his crime as he committed it? They can’t. But if he sent some of this video to Abby’s phone after the crime took place, then they know he shot video of the crime. Therefore the rumor that BG sent photos of the crime to Abby’s phone seems to be true.

In addition, the document says that BG recorded 43 seconds of audio, presumably of the crime. No doubt this goes with the video that was shot, the video being of unknown length. We know this because in the documents, LE says they are looking for 43 seconds of audio.

LE is also looking for knives, presumably hunting knives as Leaker averred. The murder weapon in the case was a knife. This was not a gun crime in that a gun was not the murder weapon. That’s not to say the gun was not discharged into the victim(s) after they were deceased. Perhaps it was. We have no idea. But if that was the case, then this is still not a gun crime as the gun was not a homicide weapon. Then all BG is guilty of regarding shooting the gun would be mutilating a corpse.

LE is also looking for blood-soaked clothing. LE feels that this crime was so brutal (in particular the killing of Libby) that BG must have been covered in blood after he murdered that poor girl. The blood spray from such an attack would be serious. So LE is looking for the clothing he wore that day with bloodstains “seen and unseen.” I don’t understand the part about unseen bloodstains, but apparently when you get blood on your clothes, not all of it is visible and some can only be seen with special tools. Ever watched crime shows where they put a chemical on the crime scene that shows bloodstains as bright purple? I suppose they use that to uncover those unseen bloodstains.

Perhaps the most incredible fact in the document is LE stating that BG abducted the girls at precisely 2:13 PM. Why is this important? On what day did this crime occur? On February 13, or 2-13. 2:13 and 2/13. Matches up, get it? Let’s play with this a bit more. He abducted and murdered 2 girls, one of whom was 13 years old. 2-13 again. 2:13, 2/13, and 2-13.

A physician friend of mine who might as well be Dr. Spock, such is his dedication to pure logic, has cast doubt on this connection. He immediately stated, “Coincidence!” (natch) when I told him about the two 2-13’s lining up perfectly.

However, LE thinks these two 2-13’s lining up perfectly was a significant enough event to be mentioned in their documents about the case. So LE thinks that fact that BG abducted those girls at precisely 2:13 in the afternoon is no coincidence.

This is all I have from these document(s). Make of it what you will. Keep in mind that these document(s) went through different people before the came to me.

Owner -> Professional -> Fellow sleuther -> Me.

There are two people between the owner and me. What do I have? I have a photocopy of the document. Could it be faked or forged? Maybe, but the professional would not do something like that. He’s as bound by his professional ethics as I am with mine.

Crime Scene Photos

I was also able to obtain some good crime scene photos for the first time. These have been out for six months now, having first appeared on Youtube in a video. They are from the same media helicopter footage as the crime scene photos we previously released here. They were presumably taken from the part of the footage where you can see many flashes going off in a circle around a location in the woods. Obviously CSI guys photographing the crime scene. These photos have been blown up and enhanced to Hell and back by everyone and their uncle. However, the photos I will discuss today are from this video.

The author is a theoretical physicist. Not that that means much, as kooks roam all fields, and kookery doesn’t discriminate, but I do think that adds weight to his analysis. Talk about logicians. We are talking about field like math where everything you say has to be backed up by formal proof. A fasifiability is a thing, and “not even wrong” is on the tip of everyone’s tongue.

The author claims a number of startling things in this video.

Outlines of the bodies of the two victims. I’ll vouch for that one.

A crucifix. Don’t see it.

A gigantic stuffed animal. No way. I can’t believe how many people believe this. Let’s not even get into the crazy discussion of this stupid stuffed animal and the dolls. That said, many things are possible in true crime, and this is one of them. I’m just not seeing it though. Extraordinary claims and extraordinary evidence and all that. God I hate that phrase but there’s a time and place for all things.

Dolls scattered around the scene. Nigga please.

An abandoned bleach bottle. Gong!

Abandoned clothing, in particular a girl’s top. Nah.

Weird messages scrawled all over the scene. I concur that one may be possible, but the rest I can’t see at all.

CSI guys wandering the scene. Nothing but blurs.

Keep in mind that for the above to be true, BG must have constructed this entire Disney World Crime Scene in a mere 45 minutes! Either he has superhuman powers or it didn’t happen. Occam’s forces me to choose the latter. How did he get all these animals and dolls down the crime scene? Come on. This crime’s weird enough as it is without taking things to outright science fiction.

Keep in mind that a lot of people claim they can’t see a damned thing in these photos, including the victims’ bodies, or that they were looking at pixels and graphics software playing games with us. Pareidolia. I hate that word, favorite of scientistic skeptards. But time and place, etc. Even the most abused notions have a proper application.

Leaker said that the girls were “posed in a sexual tableau.” That’s interesting except no one knows what it means.

John Kelly, retired FBI profiler who does excellent work and now makes his living being a media figure, felt in this recent video that the sexual tableau referred to the girls being posed in some sort of a lesbian sex act. He also suggested that BG had a deep obsession with lesbian pornography and that people around him would be aware of this. Assuming the photos below are valid interpretations, the girls are not posed in any obvious lesbian sex act. Perhaps they are posed in a milder, less than obvious one. As you can see, Abby’s hand is close to a “certain part” of Libby’s body. Whether that counts or not I have no idea.

However, assuming the images below are correct, both girls’ legs were spread very wide after they were killed. Libby was nude and Abby was nude from the waist down. That counts as sexual tableau. He did this to humiliate the girls after their deaths. One last Parthian Thrust before he walked away into the woods history. This is the posing part.

I agree with Kelly who says that killers who pose victims (“posers”) are some of the worst ones of all. They’re dark as Hell and they’re at the far end of the psychopathic spectrum. He also said that if he’s a poser, he should have killed again by now because these guys can’t control themselves, a reflection of their extreme pathology. He said that the only reason he hasn’t killed by now is because he’s afraid. Afraid that they’re onto him. Afraid of getting caught. Afraid of that one last knock on the door before the jail bars clang shut.

I have more to say about this crime as usual, but I’ve gone on long enough. More later.

I would like to apologize for the fact that these photos are very small. See if you can enlarge them. I don’t know how to fix this right now.

 

RL, LL = Right leg, left leg. This shows the right and left legs of Libby. Her legs are spread wide. Abby’s were too, as we will see below.

 

Closeup of the victims. Libby is easier to see than Abby.

 

Enhanced. Libby on the left, Abby on the right. The figures show up better in this photo. The green object appears to be a knife lodged into Libby’s right shoulder! Whether that’s what is, I’m not sure, but it’s a good guess.

 

Closeup of Libby, showing her head, hair, the knife in the shoulder, and her chest. She may be wearing a bra?

 

The first caption points to the chest of Victim 1, Libby. The second caption points to the stupid stuffed bear I don’t believe in.

 

The yellow dots show Libby. The top one is at her head and the bottom one is to her left of her stomach. The teal dots show Abby. The top one is above her head and the bottom to the right of her stomach. The red dots are the life-sized stuffed bear I don’t believe in.

 

I could not see Abby’s body for a long time, but I can see it here circled in green. Her arms and legs are spreadeagled.

 

Outlines of both victims circled. Abby in green and Libby in blue.

 

Supposedly shows the words “R U Up?” or “Are you up?” I don’t know if that’s what it shows, but it’s possible.

 

“R U UP?” Again.

 

For those of you who enjoy divining runes, here’s your oyster. “R U UP?” Again.
Please follow and like us:
error3
fb-share-icon20
Tweet 20
fb-share-icon20

39 thoughts on “Delphi Murders Update March 26, 2021”

  1. Thank you! I can finally see the supposed bodies. Everyone talks about these aerial crime scene area photos ad nauseam, but now I can at least make out possible outlines. Some of this was hard to read, so graphic, but murder isn’t pretty

    1. Exactly. Yes, I really do think those are the bodies of those poor girls. Sure, murder isn’t pretty. The only murder stories that are somewhat comfortable to read have been so cleaned up that they’re almost not worth reading.

  2. I’m glad I followed the link from Reddit to an earlier post.

    I’ve always believed that social media was involved. I wondered if it was a planned trip and he knew of it.

    Thanks!!

      1. So does Mr. X look and sound like B.G.?
        This seems to be a pretty huge oversight that was never even commented on by Leaker.

        1. There are some photo overlays that show an almost perfect match between Mr. X and BG, but I cannot post them here. I can post them on the private site if you want to join, but it’s not free. You might want to though. We are the best Delphi sleuthing out there and have been for years.

          Mr. X’s roommate says BG’s voice is “close” to Mr. X’s. Also I have some messages from a woman who knew Mr. X and his wife and says BG’s voice is a dead ringer for Mr. X. Of course that’s not enough for a conviction but it helps to solidify suspicions in LE’s and in ours, frankly.

  3. I always felt that they were catfished and never believed it was rogue/random . Glad you are back!

    Kathi Beatty/Keith Senkbeil.

  4. I still have the same POI’S since Dec 2017. All these things you talk about go right along with them. However, they are in jail now. Personally, I feel that’s why we don’t have anymore pressers or updates. They are currently serving time. They were in Lafayette that week. They also “catfished” others on social media and one of the men was bisexual. They also were into rituals…warlocks, etc.

    1. How many of them are there? Are they male or female. Is the bisexual person a male? Were the people into witches men or women?

  5. Why would there be 2 vehicles related to “Mr. X”? If his truck was in the cemetery then it wasn’t his vehicle at the CPS building…

    Also, why was he even at the cemetery?

    1. That is an excellent question. One which I have no answer to at all. His truck was at the cemetery maybe to be a getaway car or maybe to go back at 6 PM at try to find his car keys, in which case it was originally at the CPS building and then he moved it over to the cemetery at 6 PM. He parked by the cemetery to ask permission from Ron Logan to search his land. He later said he lost his car keys and was looking for them. Perhaps he lost them during the homicide if he committed it.

      Another odd thing that is that Mr. X’s phone was pinging the CPS building for a few hours around the time of the murders. Ok he left it in his car? He hid it somewhere at the CPS building?

        1. We don’t know. Those who think Mr. X is the killer think he never did find the keys he lost at the crime scene. We are not even sure where or when he lost them. And the available evidence shows no evidence that he ever found his original set of keys. At a presser, LE said, “We believe we have something of yours.” My and fellow sleuths guess is that the “something of his” that LE has is his car keys.

          But it’s all a big mystery. We don’t know LE has his keys. Maybe he did find his keys. All that is known for sure if that he lost his keys and so was searching for them in the area around the crime scene. Did he find them? We don’t know. Probably not because that evening his wife drove down and gave him an extra set of keys. Presumably they simply drove back to the house though, leaving his car there all night until it was towed the next day.

      1. Is there any place on record that Ron Logan confirms Mr X asked to search his property? I remember reading a Reddit post from 2017 that seemed to indicate it was mentioned on a local news broadcast.

        To me other than the glaring obvious “eye q” test that Mr X passes with flying colors (its so obviously him from that alone that this whole case is actually quite embarrassing on LE’s behalf if you ask me), if it can be confirmed via Logan, that’s it for me. Open and shut. Unbelievable.

        What possible explanation could Mr X. have for needing to search his property? He lost his keys? They barely knew the girls were missing at 6 pm. What are the odds a guy who to a T resembles BG is needing to “search” in an area that later becomes where these two girls were brutally murdered?

        I’m disappointed in the media and news outlets for not investigating this further. Everyone is so worried about falsely accusing innocent individuals, but people forget that those falsely accused are usually vindicated. There isn’t one mention of this guy anywhere. I mean you have to really look into stuff to find this info out, but when you really think about it, he’s literally one of the first people the police interfaced when the whole thing began.

        Why, if this guy has been secretly a suspect, does the coy language Delphi LE use seem to indicate that there’s some missing piece of evidence they need to catch the killer? That’s nonsense.

        All that’s needed is probably a search of Mr X’s internet history and I bet you’ll have all the answers you’ll ever need. I really hate to imply this but fuck it, I’m just going to put this out there. I feel almost like LE is just waiting for people to forget about this case and one day its going to become very clear that they’ve just been covering for B. I mean Mr.X.

        1. They’ve got nothing on this guy is what it boils down to. All the evidence against him is interesting, but it’s not enough to take it to court. I think the one last piece of evidence was that they were trying to crack the friend’s alibi. Remember when they said, “We will protect you!”? Ok they know that this friend is lying about seeing him in some other town at the time of the crime.

          So they’re saying, “Look, come clean. Recant your alibi and admit you lied and we won’t prosecute you. Not even the tiniest charge. All will be forgotten.” If they can crack that alibi somehow, they can make an arrest, except the alibi is dead! So that complicates matters.

          I guess. I’m not quite sure. They also need to place Mr. X at the CPS building during the crime and they can’t. They can place his phone there but not him or his vehicle. If they can place him at the CPS building, they can make an arrest.

          They also need to somehow connect Mr. X to the catfish on Snapchat in some way or other. Then they can arrest.

          So there’s a few ways they could make an arrest now but it doesn’t look real hopeful.

          On the other hand, LE now suspects Mr. X of being the Evansdale Killer, so we have a serial on our hands. Also we now have two cases where we can try to gather evidence against him. If they can’t get him on Delphi, perhaps they can arrest him for Evansdale. He would have been 46 years old when he did Evansdale.

          That’s quite late to do your first serial killing. Also Mr. X does have a sex crime history from age 16-26 which makes perfect sense. The idea that this guy woke up at age 51 and decided to commit a masterful double murder stretches credulity. He carried out that crime like a master criminal. He’s very good at what he does. That means he didn’t just start doing this and it means he’ll be hard to catch too.

          Thx for stopping by, Paul. Your comment is appreciated!

        2. Yes, there is a Youtube broadcast where he says that Mr. X asked to search his property at that time.

      2. There have been whispers on reddit that BG rented a vehicle that day. Could explain the white truck/van, and why LE have not been able to link it to BG/Mr. X

    1. Fine. Tell you what. I have heard stories about ISP and the FBI denying all of Leaker’s statements. Can you show me somewhere where the FBI is commenting on my site. People have asked them previously, and they said, “We don’t care about him (Lindsay). And an ISP detective told me, “We don’t care what you write. You can write anything you want.” I know the FBI is mad about my articles on the Evansdale Killer because the guy I’m talking about is a major suspect. They think the articles will make it hard for him to get a fair trial.

      Link me to somewhere, anywhere, where the FBI is denying what I write here on this site.

  6. I’m trembling from the acknowledging some things are true about the horrific end to the girls lives. The photos I could make out so easily. Mr. X needs to step up and tell the truth. I can’t imagine anyone holding something this dastardly and evil inside.
    The author whoever she/he may be did excellent research. Plain and straight forth with no fallacious reasoning. Excellent article. Hopefully the next article will be the capture of the killer.

    1. I do not understand. Women always accuse me of being a Warlock and casting love spells on them.

  7. OK. So do the Indiana State Police pretty much know who it is but just don’t have enough to lock it down tight in court for a conviction? After 4 years, you would think the problem was they just didn’t have clear DNA linkage because Indiana didn’t have DNA swab laws for felony arrests in 2017 until the Supreme Court ruled taking DNA swabs for FELONY arrests is constitutional because it’s the same as taking fingerprints.

    1. I’m pretty sure they have the DNA of the main suspect. Problem is he discovered the girls as a member of the search party so his DNA is all over the vicinity of the crime scene. I think he cleaned up most of it though. He threw bleach over stuff and he may have thrown enough bleach to kill most of his incriminating DNA.

      Boy the way, there are cases like this all over the country where the cops think someone killed people or is even a serial killer but they simply don’t have enough evidence to take it to court. Police are 99% sure, in their own words, that the Lewiston Killer did it. Now he’s moved back to North Carolina and a bunch of similar murders of young women have occurred there. There’s a guy in the Bay Area who killed little girls over a period of 10-15 years. Cops think he did it, they just don’t have enough on him.

      He admits to being a pedophile, goes to the graves and leaves flowers, and even visits the parents of the girls pretending to bear sympathy for them. He’s flaunting it like crazy. A cop in a nearby city said he killed those girls and he sued and won $50,000. A guy wrote a book accusing him of doing it. There are cases like this all over the country. It’s often just one homicide, but cops think he did it. Like the OJ case. Some are so dangerous that cops say they have to watch them all the time. A lot of people are under surveillance in this country, you have no idea.

  8. So, if the meeting between the girls and BG was set up via Snapchat, and the adults at the bar were talking about it, has ISP or anyone else spoken to those adults?

    1. I don’t know what the people at the bar were saying. They were just saying that the girls were going to the bridge that day. I really doubt if the girls told their parents that they were going there to meet some boy because both guardians think these girls had zero sexual experience or maybe even interest. In which case, both of the guardians would be wrong. I’m certain the girls kept that secret. The guardians had no idea they were talking to a catfish on social media.

      1. About 3 years ago I read somewhere that after he tells the girls to go down the hill, almost immediately they began screaming and he was growling at them on the recording. Do you know if there is any truth to that? I’ve been afraid to ask about that this whole time for fear of getting a virtual beating. I’m not saying it’s true, people. Just asking.

        1. I’ve never heard that one.

          I’ve been afraid to ask about that this whole time for fear of getting a virtual beating.

          I don’t blame you. I get those about this stupid case all the time.

  9. So, my question is this… granted, they may not have enough evidence to arrest Mr X, but it sounds like they had plenty of evidence to secure and execute a search warrant on his home and vehicle immediately following the discovery of the bodies… the fact that A. He found the bodies and B. His phone was pinging at the CPS building (forget the rest of his suspicious behavior for now)… so the question: why no search warrant?

    1. Simple. This guy is “juiced in” with local authorities and runs with the “Good Ol’ Boy” network. They are not about to implicate one or more of their own, so they’ve relied on misdirection and omission of key procedures that would have pretty much guaranteed a conviction, not to mention an arrest. Time has eroded the evidence (witnesses, crime scene, etc.) by now – there won’t be any arrests, period. These bastards (I wholeheartedly believe more than one perp is involved!) will walk scot-free. I’d LOVE to be very wrong on this!

      This network has also likely used the bad reputation of some of the family members against them due to prior arrests and perhaps even past/current involvement in local crimes, not to mention out and out threats. Nothing gets someone to do (or not do) what you want them to like a threat or violent action against a family member.

      Mr X. is thick as thieves with the McBrothers and the Carroll County Sheriff – I believe L&A’s tragic murders are connected to a much more sinister set of crimes. Drug trafficking, human trafficking, sex crimes, you name it.

      I go back and forth on whether this was:

      A) An abduction/assault attempt (via a “catfish” scenario) that went wrong, so the girls had to be killed

      B) A message sent to the family Mafia-style, with the girls as collateral damage. With any Organized Crime situation, your enemies (known and unknown) often come after your loved ones to get you to capitulate.

      I said this previously and will say it again: I truly wish someone with some guts and a large bank account would hire a real Private Investigator (like a Bo Dietl) that could come in and not only have this case solved in about a month, but literally blow the lid off of the shitstorm that is terrorizing Delphi/Carroll County.

      Carroll County Sheriffs Department: it’s time for you to hand over what you know and step down. You have run a compromised and ineffective investigation. The citizens, the families and most importantly L&A deserve better.

      1. Hi J! Can we talk about some of the ways he is “juiced-in” with these people? I find this very interesting! How is he connected to the McBrothers? I figured he was friends with Tobe. I also have read that he has hunted with Greeno before.

        1. L, this conversation probably needs to be taken over to the private group. I don’t think I should allow it on here. Problem is it’s not free.

      2. J., this conversation probably needs to be taken over to the private group. I don’t think I should allow it on here. Problem is it’s not free.

    2. Hi Dan, we don’t know if a search warrant has been issued for Mr. X, his home, or his vehicle. And we don’t know if any of these three have been searched by police either. Maybe they have, maybe they haven’t. There’s so much we don’t know about this case, and LE isn’t exactly helping matters.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.