The Role of Jews in the Left and Communism in the 20th Century

A commenter asks why there are so many Jews in the Communist Party USA. When I was getting their newspaper in 1998, it was stacked with Jews from top to bottom.

Don’t they know the the USSR effectively turned anti-Jewish starting from 1948? And being the most privileged elite group in America, what do they have to gain by being in the CPUSA?

Jews are very leftwing people. A lot of them are liberals, socialists, Leftists or out and out Communists. As far as why this is, much ink has been expended. You are urged to look into it yourself, and see what you can come up with. This is one of the Fascist Right’s main arguments against Jews – that they are a bunch of Commies. That’s why Hitler and the other fascists killed 6 million Jews in the Holocaust, to wipe out Judeo-Bolshevism.

The White nationalist Right and the Kevin MacDonald types continue to recycle this meme about Commie Jews who hate Whites and kill Whites. They go on and on about Bolshevik Jews who murdered 20-110 million Russian Christians, or some shit like that. This is the Czarist and fascist Solzhenitzen’s beef against Jews – they’re a bunch of Commies. Or they bring up Bela Kun. Or the German Communists in 1919-1920. Or the Polish Communists. Or on and on.

That’s one of the reasons I am a Judeophile. Jews are my comrades. They are one of the most Leftist ethnic groups that ever lived, and they played a great role in the development of the Left from 1850-on, a role that continues to this day.

There’s nothing great about Stalin turning anti-Jewish at the end, just more Stalinist paranoia and murder. The Jews built the Bolshevik state up from nothing. They created the state that Stalin ruled.

Most modern-day Stalinists and Communists are actually pro-Jewish, especially the ones in the Russia nowadays. Remember that Stalin made anti-Semitism illegal in 1926, and made the punishment the death penalty. I’m glad he did that! Plus he married some Jewish women and had some Jewish mistresses. He didn’t hate Jews at all; it’s a bunch of anti-Semitic wishful thinking shit.

Ilya Ehrenberg, a Jew, was Stalin’s chief propagandist in WW2. He wrote, “You’re either an anti-Semite or anti-Nazi, there is no middle ground.” He drew the line in the sand, and I still agree with that line.

The fascists still hate Ehrenberg with a passion so hot it could smelt iron. Go over to Stormfront and praise Ilya Ehrenberg, and they will probably try to lynch you on the spot.

Please follow and like us:
error0
fb-share-icon20
Tweet 20
fb-share-icon20

34 thoughts on “The Role of Jews in the Left and Communism in the 20th Century”

  1. Dear Robert
    The Dutch-American Jew Ernest van den Haag once said it best: “Of 100 Jews, only 5 will be radicals, but of 10 radicals, 5 will be Jewish”.
    Part of the explanation for the overrepresentation of Jews among communists is that communism, like libertarianism, tends to attract intellectuals, and Jews are overrepresented among intellectuals because of their above-average IQ. Don’t forget that Jews are also overrepresented among libertarians.
    Cheers. James

  2. Rob, the ethnic Russians and Han Chinese are the most leftist ethnic groups that ever lived, not the Jews. And you’re mistaken about Russian Stalinists; they are anti-Zionist and they are still angry about the Jewish role in the downfall of the USSR and their looting of Russia in the 1990s through criminal oligarchs. Stalinists are actually partnering with people you call “fascist”, so you are mistaken when you say present-day Russian Stalinists are pro-Jewish.

    1. NS Germany surely had a German spirit. Was Communism based on Russian farm culture or anything native? I often think it contrasts with warring Celtic tribes on the British Isles and Ireland. Maybe some of it is Slavic in nature.

      1. Geez, it really is a giant red snake. What little Communist literature I’ve read seemed very pro-German, Ehrenberg? No, I believe it was Engels. He was also very soft on Jews. Maybe the great unifier early on was Jews. Seems like a lot the men that married Jews ended up hating them.

  3. How can you say Stalin became paranoid in 1948-1953 when you yourself wrote that Jews started spying for America during this period?

    1. Some of them did. Some of them started spying. Ok. But he went on a murder spree and started executing all sorts of Jewish intellectuals. On what basis? Were they all spying for the West? Prove it. Stalin was simply a murderer in a lot of ways. A lot of the people he killed were good revolutionaries, and they had to be innocent of any wrongdoing. Stalin was a paranoid murderer.

      1. Once Germany was defeated, Jews no longer had any reason to support the USSR, so they switched sides and joined the Amerikwan imperialists.

      2. Yes, he was paranoid. Just as the most of man in great power (including democratic leaders and financial tops). Paranoid pepole are “natural born leaders”, who actively seek the power everywhere, not just Russia. As for using brutal violence, some philisopher believed that only violence may crush the power of money (there is the demon of money, fetish worship). Perhaps he was wrong, especially because the system tied to power of single man may break (which Trotsky knew well). And that happened after Stalin’s death, dissolve of USSR began in 60’s, not 90’s.
        Still Stalin was not so stupid, he was not anti-Jewish, he was anti-Zionist (which are really different things).

        However if you see closely the violence and the money are always walking together. Bodyguards, gangs and so on.

  4. My own theory of Ashkenazi Jews is that they’re a people without an underclass, probably because they’re so damn smart, and have always had to make use of other people’s underclasses to meet their ends, which like most people’s tend to be economic.

    This creates two problems. One, people don’t like foreign overlords. They tolerate their own, but when they’re different, they’re liable to hate them. Two, many Jews, then feeling guilty, decide that they can correct all the problems of their adopted underclass and go on moral crusades. Now, people can’t stand being ruled by foreigners but they loathe even more being told how to run their lives by them.

    Nowadays the Ashkenazi Jews in Israel have reconciled with their long-lost underclass. Which seems to be an unfortunate base that comes with nationhood.

      1. There is a Jewish underclass there too. The Mizrachi Jews and especially the Ethiopian Jews. The Ethiopians live in ghettos, flunk out of school, don’t work and are on welfare, have tons of kids…Sound familiar? Ahem.

        Anyway, I have heard that the Israeli government sterilizes the Ethiopian Jewish women, I hope not forcefully. No Ashkenazi Jew wants their kid marrying an Ethiopian.

        1. What accounts for the higher Ashkenazi IQ? Is it from living in a cold climate in eastern Europe instead of in their original sunny Mediterranean homeland? Or perhaps Slavic genes?

        2. No Ashkenazi Jew wants their kid marrying an Ethiopian.

          Yeah, so much for “Judaism isn’t a race, but a religion” nonsense.

          At least in the case of Ashkenazi Jews, Judaism for them is indeed a race.

  5. I don’t know, Robert, I don’t see how you can be a philo-semite.

    Yes, I know that as a leftist, you have a thing for them.

    But keep in mind the fact that you’re an economic leftist. Many Jews, on the other hand, are Cultural Marxist leftists.

    Of course, not to mention neoconservatism.

    I don’t see how you can have such feelings of affection for a people who created both Cultural Marxism and neoconservatism.

    Who knows? Perhaps the Jews in the Communist party that you knew were genuine economic leftists, as opposed to Cultural Marxist false leftists.

    As for me, as a white advocate, I cannot have fond feelings for Jews. The opening up of our borders, PC Cultural Marxism, neocon imperialism, you name it, all have many Jewish fingerprints on them.

    1. The average Jew is like the average Black. They don’t like Cultural Marxism, Open Borders, or neoconservatism. At least the ones I know anyway.

      True, most Jews are for Open Borders, but big deal. They’re 2% of the population? How important could they be? They have tons of White Gentiles supporting them on the Open Borders crap. The Jews could not do this alone. And the entire Republican Party is neocon now. Vast majority of them are White Gentiles. Many White Gentiles are into Cultural Marxism now, and of course the young minorities are too. We don’t need Jews to do any of these crazy things to us. We White Gentiles are doing this stuff to ourselves.

  6. Rob, what evidence do you have that present-day Stalinists in Russia are pro-Jewish? And were the Jews that you know personally from CPUSA Trotskyites? What were their opinions of Stalin and post-1948 USSR?

    1. CPUSA are not Trots. They never talked about Stalin. They supported the USSR. CPUSA had fraternal relations with the CCCP from the 1950’s on. CPUSA supports all foreign CP’s and has fraternal relations with them, last time I checked. They are like the official CP of the US.

      1. But if CPUSA was heavily Jewish, didn’t they they know that post-1948, the USSR was anti-Jewish? And what evidence do you have that Russian Stalinists are pro-Jewish? It seems counter-intuitive because Zyuganov, the head of the Russian CP, has more in common with the National Bolsheviks and Francis Parker Yockey than traditional communists.

  7. ” but he went on a murder spree and started executing all sorts of Jewish intellectuals…” 1948 – 53? You must be talking about that doctors’ plot thing, right? It wasn’t just a general assault on jewish intellectuals.

    No, jews didn’t build up the soviet union, even if they were over-represented in the bolsheviks. I get the impression that the Russian middle-class, the administrative class, wouldn’t co-operate with the revolution, and more jews than anyone else had the skills to replace them. My feeling about this now is that the bolsheviks shouldn’t have taken power under these circumstances; they should have sought a compromise that would bring the middle classes on board. Without that they had no real mandate. All due respect to the real achievements of the SU, especially under Stalin, but the working class were NEVER in power for a second.

    If the ‘left’ is 50% jewish it’s NOT ‘left’! So what is it? ‘Left’ means representing the interests of the ‘working class’ (whatever variety) against the rentier and capital-owning class. A ‘left’ political group must be OF that class, not a separate caste. So these 50% jewish ‘lefts’ are not ‘lefts’ but jewish organisations. Sad but true.

    ‘Cultural Marxism’ is a misnomer. The name exists to discredit Marx, who wrote ‘a lot of good stuff’ as well as ‘a load of shite’. The practices (of cultural Marxism) seem obviously dreamed up in the think tanks of the rich elites; its purpose is to, as Confucius recommended, ‘correct the language’ in line with ruling class requirements i. e. to demote and obscure ‘class’ concerns.

    The other Marxism, ‘revolutionary’ Marxism, as still represented by the parties and sects, seems to me now not a jewish conspiracy but a jewish hobby, a harmless replacement for Talmudic studies for a certain class of jew who basically doesn’t like to work. That’s all. Fair play to them – a man should have a hobby. But politically, as regards our struggle against the bloodsucking financial elites, they’re just a waste of everybody’s time.

  8. Did you guys hear about the border shootout between Israeli and Lebanese troops? Looks like Judea and Phoenicia are about to go at it. Watch out for August 10th, which is when IsraHELL may strike Iran and cause WWIII.

    1. Do you really think that even Israel will attack Iran?

      Although, with both neocons and Israel clamoring for war, that’s a possibility.

      Seriously, why isn’t there more anti-Israeli activity beyond the short-lived Israeli Apartheid Week at my university?

      Why is it that South Africa was vilified, sanctioned, etc (and rightfully so), but we don’t see the same energy directed towards Israel. In fact, unlike South Africa, to criticize Israel can open you up to charges of bigotry.

      I think we all know the answer why South Africa was widely condemned, but Israel is not.

      1. Go the “revolt of the plebes” website and Keith Johnson has an excellent article about it. And these cretins wonder why their filthy Talmudic asses are hated by virtually all Gentiles they come in contact with, except of course the retarded American sheeple.

  9. Again Rob, do you have any evidence that current-day Russian Stalinists are pro-Jewish? Zyuganov sure seems to refute this. And what the fuck have Jews really done for Russia except being subversive fifth-columns and all-around pain in the asses.

  10. I had a look at that Revolt of the Plebs site. Wow! That guy’s good. I’ll read that regularly now.

  11. “Some of them did. Some of them started spying. Ok. But he went on a murder spree and started executing all sorts of Jewish intellectuals. On what basis?”

    On the basis they were counterrevolutionarily setting up their own state in Israel and on the basis they try to take over everything they see. Stalin showed them who was boss. He stepped on their necks before they could step on his. Once he was dead they looted Russia and moved on.

  12. Who cares? I have a way of making money. My belly is full. I have a house. I fuck when I want to. I go to bed when I get tired and get up when I can’t sleep any more.
    I have damn near everything I ever wanted.

    Reg. Jews and the extent of their influence, I couldn’t care less.

  13. Regarding UNDERCLASS JEWS you people write

    ———————-

    erranter
    August 3, 2010 at 5:44 AM

    My own theory of Ashkenazi Jews is that they’re a people without an underclass, probably because they’re so damn smart, and have always had to make use of other people’s underclasses to meet their ends, which like most people’s tend to be economic.

    This creates two problems. One, people don’t like foreign overlords. They tolerate their own, but when they’re different, they’re liable to hate them. Two, many Jews, then feeling guilty, decide that they can correct all the problems of their adopted underclass and go on moral crusades. Now, people can’t stand being ruled by foreigners but they loathe even more being told how to run their lives by them.

    Nowadays the Ashkenazi Jews in Israel have reconciled with their long-lost underclass. Which seems to be an unfortunate base that comes with nationhood.
    Reply

    fpy3p
    August 3, 2010 at 5:48 AM

    Are you referring to Palestinians when you say “long-lost underclass”?
    Reply
    Robert Lindsay
    August 3, 2010 at 6:15 AM

    There is a Jewish underclass there too. The Mizrachi Jews and especially the Ethiopian Jews. The Ethiopians live in ghettos, flunk out of school, don’t work and are on welfare, have tons of kids…Sound familiar? Ahem.

    Anyway, I have heard that the Israeli government sterilizes the Ethiopian Jewish women, I hope not forcefully. No Ashkenazi Jew wants their kid marrying an Ethiopian.
    ———————————————-

    IT MIGHT SURPRISE YOU THAT THERE HAS ALWAYS BEEN AN UNDERCLASS amongst the White Askenazi Jews and many of them in Brooklyn today are on government welfare, foodstamps, medicaid, etc

  14. The Jews did murder 25 million Christians in Russia from 1917 to 1990 that is a fact not fiction! Just like there plans are lay out in The Protocals of the Elders of Zion! How could something that was forged come to be so true today!

  15. Geez, it really is a giant red snake. What little Communist literature I’ve read seemed very pro-German, Ehrenberg? No, I believe it was Engels. He was also very soft on Jews. Maybe the great unifier early on was Jews. Seems like a lot the men that married Jews ended up hating them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *