In the comments section, White Preservation, who is a White separatist, states:
Do note though that in all countries that are very multiracial/multiethnic (USA, Brazil, India, etc) race and ethnicity often correlates quite closely with class-status, with the lower classes of multiracial/multiethnic nations always being of a ‘darker’ racial/ethnic heritage.
Thus, if those chaotic multiracial nations were calmly dissolved and the races then re-separated and re-organized again as best they could manage, then the very troublesome and explosive class/race correlation could largely be done away with and humanity would certainly be better for it.
There are some serious problems with this analysis. Much less so for the US, but the problems in India and Brazil are so severe as to utterly preclude any kind of racial separatism. Why? There are hardly any “races” to separate anymore.
Not necessarily so true in India. The very intelligent and cultured Brahmins of South India are often much darker than the much less intelligent and very backwards low castes of North India. It’s not so simple. Besides, it makes no sense to divide India into two races, Light North Indians and Dark South Indians. It’s just ridiculous.
The place is a totally chaotic racial/ethnic mishmash, with darker folks also in the north, lighter folks also in the south, and people with all sorts of mixed features of both. It would just be insane to try to separate out any kind of real races out of the mix, and anyway, a lot of darker folks would align more with lighter and a lot of lighter folks would align more with darker, due to caste, intelligence, class and cultural variables.
Intelligence is more along caste lines than along racial lines. The Brahmins are smarter than the others.
Further, there is no support whatsoever in Brazil for racial separatism. There are a few Whites down south who advocate this, but honestly, they just have no support at all. And they have been squawking about this forever.
Even in Brazil, it is going to be very difficult to tease out any kind of real races. Sure, down South, you often have folks that are pretty White, but I have seen genetic tests done down there that show that even a lot of Southern Brazilian Whites have lots of Indian and Black in them.
In most of Brazil, all “White” means is at least somewhat lighter than others. There are Black people, true, but most of the population is just some unholy Godawful genetic mystery casserole such that “racial separation” makes no sense because there are hardly any races to separate out anymore.
It’s true that in the US, there is still a White population of 65% or so that looks White and tends to have a White culture, but Hispanics are a real problem. What about White Hispanics? Would they be able to live in the White state? And at what point do you consider a White Hispanic to still be White, and at what point do you consider them to no longer be White?
The US isn’t all that mixed in yet, so separation is still doable (other than it has almost 0% support) but as we get more and more racially jumbled up, the racial separatism project gets progressively more and more insane as you can hardly figure out what race anyone is anymore.